Skip to main content

Mystery of Consciousness – The Hard Problem







Philosophers and scientists have been at war for decades over the question of what makes human beings more than complex robots.  "The Guardian" -   One spring morning in Tucson, Arizona, in 1994, an unknown philosopher named David Chalmers got up to give a talk on consciousness, by which he meant the feeling of being inside your head, looking out – or, to use the kind of language that might give a neuroscientist an aneurysm, of having a soul. Though he didn’t realise it at the time, the young Australian academic was about to ignite a war between philosophers and scientists, by drawing attention to a central mystery of human life – perhaps the central mystery of human life – and revealing how embarrassingly far they were from solving it.

Next week, the conundrum will move further into public awareness with the opening of Tom Stoppard’s new play, The Hard Problem, at the National Theatre – the first play Stoppard has written for the National since 2006, and the last that the theatre’s head, Nicholas Hytner, will direct before leaving his post in March. The 77-year-old playwright has revealed little about the play’s contents, except that it concerns the question of “what consciousness is and why it exists”, considered from the perspective of a young researcher played by Olivia Vinall. Speaking to the Daily Mail, Stoppard also clarified a potential misinterpretation of the title. “It’s not about erectile dysfunction,” he said.  "The Guardian"; January 21, 2015 http://bit.ly/1uoKMl0







Tom Stoppard’s new play, The Hard Problem is playing at the National Theatre, London from 21 January 2015 [1]. To understand this news, we begin with the chart for the New Moon. The New Moon of January 20 took place in the 9th house at London. This house is associated with philosophy, science, religion  and higher consciousness including mysticism and inspired thoughts [2]. The New Moon is sextile Saturn which has just entered Sagittarius on December 23, 2014. When Saturn travels through a sign, his lessons take on the qualities of that sign.  Being the 9th sign, Sagittarius has a one-to-one correspondence  with the 9th house and therefore also deals with issues of consciousness. Notice that Saturn is square Neptune. Neptune is the archetype of the transcendent, of ideal reality, of imagination and the spiritual. It represents the ocean of consciousness that dissolves all boundaries between self and other, between self and universe, between self and God, and between this concrete reality and other realities. But  Saturn  represents our  consensus reality so that when it aspects Neptune, it demands concrete and practical explanations about consciousness from elusive and hard-to-pin-down Neptune.

Another element of the chart that resonates with the above theme is the Mercury-Jupiter opposition that aligns with the meridian.

Mercury represents the concrete mind, thinking, and the movement or exchange of ideas through speaking, writing, and other forms of communication. It governs the capacity to conceptualize and communicate, to articulate, to use words and language, to analyze and comprehend, to learn, to perceive, to mediate, transport, and connect.
Jupiter  represents our ability to grasp meaning and is therefore connected to higher consciousness. When it opposes Mercury, as it does here, it challenges Mercury to expand its  limited ability to conceptualize and communicate this “higher consciousness”.

Finally, let us note that Mercury on the MC is conjunct Venus – the ruler of the 5th house of the chart. This house is associated with “theatres and plays” [3]

So it would appear that the astrology of the  New Moon does summarize the challenges presented by the new play.








Comments